Open Dapt OD logoOpen Dapt

AI Answers Now Pick Which Contractors Get the Call. Here's Who Gets Named.

Four studies published this month show how Google's AI Overviews and ChatGPT narrow a page of contractors down to a handful of names. Here's who gets named, where the AI looks, and three things to fix this week.

Illustration: beams from a glowing orb over a suburban street light up a few service vans at night
Illustration: OpenDapt.

When a homeowner asks an AI who to call, it doesn't hand back a page of links. It names a few companies, and if yours isn't one of them, you may never know the job existed.

That's not a prediction. It's what several studies published this month measured. Nobody is "stealing" your leads. But the step where a homeowner decides who to call is moving into an AI answer, and that answer has room for only a few names.

Google's AI answer now sits on top of most "who should I hire" searches

In October, marketer Mike Purvis published The State of AI Visibility in Home Services. He asked 30 homeowner-style questions ("Best plumber in Dallas," "Who should I have check my roof after a hailstorm in Denver") across ten metros and three AI engines, every day from Aug. 19 to Sept. 17, 2026. That's 27,000 answers.

On 84% of those Google searches, an AI answer sat on top of the maps pack, the ads and the listings. Most of those answers named at least one company, typically three or four.

A separate study by Lilach Bullock, published Oct. 8, found an AI Overview on 88% of 400 local-service searches in the US and UK. It appeared on every "how much does it cost" search she checked.

When the AI answer shows up, fewer people click

Pew Research Center tracked the browsing of 900 US adults. It found that people clicked a regular search result on 8% of visits when Google showed an AI summary, compared with 15% when it didn't. They clicked a link inside the summary on just 1% of visits.

"Users who encountered an AI summary clicked on a traditional search result link in 8% of all visits."

Pew Research Center, July 2025

Pew looked at all kinds of searches, not just local ones. So treat it as a direction, not your exact loss. The pattern is consistent, though. When the answer comes to the homeowner, fewer homeowners come to your website.

Not every search is affected yet

Here's the honest good news. Bullock found that short "near me" searches are still mostly the map's job. Only 5 of 40 showed an AI Overview, while 39 of 40 showed the map pack.

The shift is in question searches, the full sentences a homeowner types or says when something's broken. Those are exactly the searches where an AI answer now usually appears.

Who gets named, and who doesn't

In Purvis's data, a national company showed up in 53% of Google's AI answers, 57% of ChatGPT's and 56% of Perplexity's. Independents showed up in 33%, 47% and 32%.

8ight, a firm that sells AI-visibility services, published a study on Oct. 5 that asked ChatGPT and Claude "Who is the best {trade} in {city}?" for 39 trades. ChatGPT named about 12% of the Google Maps businesses it was checked against. A few findings stand out for owners:

  • Reviews help, but they're not enough. ChatGPT named 3.4% of businesses with fewer than 25 Google reviews and 22.2% of those with 1,000 or more. Even so, the most-reviewed business in a city was left off the list about three times in four.
  • Star ratings didn't separate anyone. Named and unnamed businesses both had a median 4.9 stars.
  • The AI reads different sources than you'd expect. ChatGPT cited the Better Business Bureau in 39% of answers and government or licensing sites in 25%. It cited Yelp in none. Claude cited Yelp in 93%.
  • The list moves. Ask ChatGPT the same question again about 39 minutes later, and only about 29% of the businesses named overlapped.

Then there's the basic housekeeping. Adimize audited 23 home-service businesses between Sept. 10 and Oct. 15 (published Oct. 16). Of the 13 with AI-tracking data, 6 had never been mentioned by ChatGPT, Google's AI Overviews, AI Mode or Gemini. Sixteen of the 23 had listings that disagreed with their own name, phone, address or hours. That's a small sample, so read it as a pattern, not a national rate.

OpenDapt's view: the AI isn't taking your customers. It's making a shortlist before they ever call you, and right now most owners can't see that list.

How a homeowner finds a pro: 2020 vs. 2026

2020 2026
First move Types "plumber near me" into Google Asks Google, ChatGPT or another assistant a full question ("My water heater is leaking, who should I call?")
What they see Map pack, ads, a page of links An AI answer on top naming a few companies, often 3 or 4 (Purvis)
How they choose Clicks a few sites, calls two or three Calls whoever the answer named, or lets an assistant call for them (Invoca)
What decides it Ranking, ads, reviews Reviews still matter, plus BBB, licensing records, directories and your own site (8ight)

AI is already calling, too

This isn't only about being named. In Invoca's tracking from July to November 2025, plumbing businesses answered just 66% of calls placed by Google's AI to ask about pricing. And on Oct. 6, ServiceTitan launched Homh, which it says lets AI assistants like ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude book selected contractors. It's early and invite-only, but the direction is clear. We covered both yesterday.

Three things to do this week

  1. Ask the question yourself, more than once. Type "Who's the best [your trade] in [your city]?" into ChatGPT and into Google. Do it on two different days and write down who's named. One check proves little, because the list changes.
  2. Fix your public record. Check your BBB profile and your state license lookup, and make sure your name, phone, address and hours match everywhere. ChatGPT reads licensing and BBB pages, and mismatched listings were common in Adimize's audit.
  3. Answer the questions homeowners ask, on your own site. Put a clear service page for each service and city, plus a straight answer on price ranges. Bullock found local businesses' own sites earned about 35% of AI Overview citations, more than directories, marketplaces and social sites combined.

Where OpenDapt fits

This is the problem we work on. OpenDapt helps home-service businesses get set up so customers' personal AI agents can find, reach and book them. If you want to see where your shop stands, start at opendapt.com.

About the author
Tyler Frazier is the founder of OpenDapt, which helps home-service businesses get set up so customers' personal AI agents can reach and book them. More about Tyler and OpenDapt.

Sources

  1. Mike Purvis, GetFoundForLocal, The State of AI Visibility in Home Services, 2026 Baseline Edition (Oct. 2026; data Aug. 19–Sept. 17, 2026)
  2. Lilach Bullock, AI Overviews Local Services Study 2026 (Oct. 8, 2026)
  3. 8ight, Ask an AI for a roofer (Oct. 5, 2026)
  4. Adimize, 23 Home Service Websites vs. AI Search (Oct. 16, 2026)
  5. Pew Research Center, Google users are less likely to click on links when an AI summary appears (July 22, 2025)
  6. Invoca study press release (Dec. 10, 2025)
  7. ServiceTitan press release, Pantheon 2026 (Oct. 6, 2026)